The Appeal of Industrial Sale-leaseback Transactions
Benefits for both investors and tenants are driving demand
Let’s start with the foundation: if you’re unfamiliar with the term sale-leaseback, you should go here. For a more focused explanation relating to industrial properties, let’s turn to Erik Foster, principal with Avison Young and head of the firm’s industrial capital markets practice.
“A sale-leaseback is when a user of real estate who owns their premises chooses to monetize that real estate. They stay in [the property], occupy it for a long term and sell it to a third-party owner who becomes the landlord, and the occupier becomes a tenant,” Foster told LoopNet.
According to Foster, sale-leaseback transactions for industrial assets have been surging over the past several years, with interest in North American industrial properties emanating from across the world. “It’s truly become a global marketplace,” Foster said.
This interest in industrial real estate is neither new nor particularly surprising. As Foster noted, the sector has been experiencing record low vacancies amid historic levels of investment activity. And these factors, which have intensified during the pandemic, have created what Foster described as “a very exuberant investment atmosphere.”
And industrial users are increasingly taking note of this enthusiasm.
Historically, industrial users have been more apt to own their facilities than their office or retail counterparts. Where most office and retail properties are typically developed with the expectation that multiple tenants will occupy the property, some types of industrial properties are more commonly utilized by a single user. Moreover, industrial properties are often heavily customized to meet the manufacturing or specialized logistical requirements of a particular business.
But industrial users are beginning to realize that they may be able to possess their proverbial cake and consume it too. “Industrial users are finding that they can reap the rewards of the sale of their building at record pricing, but still maintain occupancy and the use, so nothing really changes for them,” Foster said.
Of course, few things in commercial real estate are without caveats. To gain a better understanding of the industrial sale-leaseback phenomenon, LoopNet spoke with Foster — as well as Gino Sabatini, head of investments and managing director of W. P. Carey — and they walked us through the attributes and challenges of this process for both users and investors.
An Opportunity for Industrial Users to Acquire Capital and Flexibility
According to Foster, for the industrial user, most of the advantages of a sale-leaseback transaction can be reduced to two concepts: working capital and flexibility.
Foster noted that most industrial users that own their property have some kind of financing tied to the building. Perhaps they have a loan that represents 50%, or even 60% or 70% of the building’s appraised value. This loan provides them with operating capital to reinvest into the business — for the purchase of equipment or materials, for instance.
Through a sale-leaseback transaction, a user can derive 100% of the value of their property, and reallocate that capital to other aspects of their business. Depending on the company’s accounting structure, this could vastly improve their balance sheet. “You can pay down debt, you can reinvest into your business,” Foster said.
Meanwhile, the company in question retains use of the asset. The user “gets a ton of capital out of the real estate and continues to use [the real estate] the way they always have,” Foster added. The industrial user also enhances their flexibility in the process, trading their real estate asset for “a leasehold obligation. It’s not an illiquid asset,” Foster said.
Between record-setting industrial investment activity and equally historic low interest rates, this can seem like the ideal moment for industrial users to relinquish ownership of their facilities. “W. P. Carey, and most other sale-leaseback and net-lease buyers, operate on a spread over interest rates,” Sabatini said. This means that as interest rates potentially rise in the near(ish) future, cap rates could climb alongside them.
Currently, Sabatini said that cap rates range from 4% to 7%, depending on the location and nature of the facility (more on that in a moment). Foster said that he was even “hearing about sub-3% cap rates on the coasts.”
All of these factors may make an industrial sale-leaseback transaction seem like a “best of both worlds” scenario for the user, but it’s not quite that simple. For one thing, as most industrial users are typically real estate novices, they need to make sure they carefully consider all potential suitors. “The user needs to make sure that they don’t talk to the first person that knocks on the door,” Foster said.
According to Foster, taking the property through a traditional investment sales process generally garners terms that are more beneficial to the user — both for the sale and the subsequent lease. “When we go out and we make a market for assets like this, we’re amazed at how the terms continue to become better as we work through the process.
Foster mentioned that it’s also important to find the right investor match for each particular industrial user. “Sometimes this is their only location and its critical to the [tenant/seller], so having an owner who doesn’t have any forethought or care about the user is an issue too, so you’ve just got to find the right match.”
Industrial users also need to be comfortable with the control they’re surrendering by entering into a sale-leaseback transaction. For users that are accustomed to having sole authority over their premises, that adjustment could potentially be challenging. And, as frenetic as the industrial sales market is at the moment, there are reasons to believe that prices could continue to rise.
“With the shortages in the commodities markets and the difficulty in getting steel and lumber and other materials, there’s a bit of a governor on the amount of development that can happen. So, the supply of assets is also muted, which is continuing to drive scarcity pricing,” Foster said.
Ultimately, the viability of a sale-leaseback transaction for an industrial user will come down to that particular company’s priorities and whether they value working capital and flexibility over control and security.
For investors, the calculus is a bit more fraught with risk, but potentially equally rewarding.
Conducting Due Diligence on an Industrial Sale-Leaseback Opportunity
It’s probably fair to say that W. P. Carey has more experience in industrial sale-leasebacks than any other property owner; after all, that’s been the firm’s primary focus since it was founded in 1973.
As Sabatini described it, “Sale-leasebacks of industrial buildings for sub-investment grade companies is really our bread and butter.”
When LoopNet asked what made these investments so appealing to W. P. Carey, Sabatini explained, “The facilities are often very critical to the company that is doing the sale-leaseback, and that’s very important for us; because we’re a long-term holder and we want to own something that the company is planning on using for a long period of time.”
In an ideal scenario, Sabatini said that W. P. Carey’s investment thesis is relatively simple. “We’re making a bet alongside the equity investors in that company that the company is going to be successful for a long period of time. If we’re correct, then we’ll collect rent for a 15- or 20-year primary lease term for starters, and potentially [execute] renewals as well.”
But what happens if they're wrong?
According to Sabatini, that depends largely on the market and asset in question. A highly customized property, one that will be challenging to adapt for a new tenant — such as a food or biotech manufacturing facility — represents a greater risk than a relatively generic property, like a last-mile fulfillment center. That risk expands in smaller markets and is somewhat ameliorated in larger markets.
In terms of how Sabatini approaches the due diligence process, he said that the first portion of his methodology involves elements that are fairly consistent across any real estate asset class or deal type. He advised that prospective investors commission an environmental phase I study (and a phase II study if the initial report reveals any areas for concern); have an engineer walk the property to appraise its structural integrity; and review the property survey and title.
“Make sure you’re purchasing a clean piece of real estate,” Sabatini said.
After that, you need to undertake what Sabatini says is often the more challenging facet of the process: reviewing the company who will first sell you the property and then become your tenant. Sabatini likens this phase of due diligence to the process credit organizations like Moody’s undertake when they’re rating companies.
“You try to understand the industry, the company’s position within it, as well as any threats to either the company or the industry,” he said. “You really need to dig into the credit and understand why the building is important to the company, and what the company’s financial prospects are in the short-term, the medium-term and the long-term.” Sabatini also said that it’s important to carefully review the company’s balance sheet. Specifically, you should assess their attitude towards leverage and how they have fared during downturns.
As this process illustrates, in many respects a sale-leaseback transaction isn’t a simple real estate deal; it’s more analogous to the creation of a (hopefully) long-term, mutually beneficial partnership.
Related Topics:
You May Also Like:
Sale-leaseback vs. Traditional Debt: A Company’s Guide to Evaluating the Options
For companies seeking capital to fund growth, finance an acquisition, reduce leverage or pursue other strategic priorities, traditional debt financing is often the first option considered. But companies that own significant real estate may have another source of capital available: a sale-leaseback. In a sale-leaseback, a company sells its real estate to an investor and simultaneously enters into a long-term lease, allowing it to continue operating at the property while unlocking capital otherwise tied up in a fixed asset. Unlike traditional corporate debt, a sale-leaseback does not add another loan that ultimately needs to be repaid. Instead, it converts owned real estate into liquidity while creating a long-term lease obligation. Neither approach is inherently better. The right choice depends on a company’s capital needs, strategic objectives, balance sheet priorities and long-term plans for its real estate. For companies evaluating the options, it is important to look beyond the headline cost of capital and consider the broader implications of each. Here are five factors to consider. 1. How much capital does the business need? A fundamental question is whether the financing approach can generate enough capital to accomplish the company’s objectives. Traditional debt can provide an efficient source of liquidity, but the amount a company can prudently borrow may be influenced by its existing leverage, credit profile and broader capital structure. For companies with substantial value tied up in owned real estate, a sale-leaseback provides another potential source of capital. By selling the property, the company can monetize the value of the asset and redeploy the proceeds elsewhere in the business. Those proceeds can be used for a range of strategic purposes, including funding growth initiatives, new acquisitions or reducing debt. The analysis therefore extends beyond the relative cost of capital and should focus on the company’s overall capital needs and which structure best aligns with its objectives. 2. What is the highest and best use of the company’s capital? Owning real estate can serve a business well, particularly when ownership is an important part of its long-term strategy. But it also means that capital remains invested in buildings rather than being deployed elsewhere in the company. That creates an opportunity-cost question: Could the capital currently invested in real estate generate greater strategic or financial value somewhere else? For example, a company may determine that investing in new equipment, expanding production, completing an acquisition, entering a new market or reducing existing debt better supports its strategic priorities than continuing to own its facilities. The key is to assess real estate ownership in the context of the company’s broader capital priorities. If capital invested in owned facilities could generate greater value elsewhere in the business, a sale-leaseback may be worth considering as part of the overall financing strategy. If ownership itself provides strategic value, retaining the property while raising capital through traditional debt may make more sense. 3. How does each option affect the company’s balance sheet? Financing decisions cannot be evaluated in isolation from a company’s overall capital structure. Traditional borrowing introduces additional debt and associated interest and repayment obligations. A sale-leaseback, by contrast, monetizes an existing asset and introduces a long-term lease obligation. The resulting accounting, tax and credit implications will depend on the business and the specific transaction, so companies should evaluate each structure with their accounting, tax and legal teams. Strategically, however, the distinction is important. A company looking to preserve debt capacity or reduce existing borrowings may evaluate a sale-leaseback differently from a company comfortable adding incremental leverage. The key is determining how each source of capital fits into the company’s broader financial strategy, rather than evaluating the transaction on its own. 4. What does the company’s long-term strategy look like? The appropriate financing structure also depends on where the business expects to be several years from now. A company taking on traditional debt should consider its ability to repay or refinance those obligations alongside its other capital needs. A company considering a sale-leaseback needs to think differently. Because it will enter into a lease, management should have conviction that the facility will continue to support the business's operations over that period. That makes the expected future role of the property an important part of the decision. A mission-critical facility that a company expects to occupy over the long term may be well suited to a sale-leaseback. A property that could become unnecessary as the company’s footprint changes may warrant a different strategy. 5. What flexibility will the company need in the future? Companies evolve. Production capacity changes, operations expand, facilities require modernization and sustainability investments become necessary. When weighing a sale-leaseback against traditional debt financing, companies should consider the flexibility each provides as the business evolves. A sale-leaseback can offer a different type of flexibility by pairing access to capital with a long-term real estate partner that may be able to support future property needs. W. P. Carey’s Carey Tenant Solutions platform, for example, is designed to support tenants beyond the initial acquisition through follow-on investments, including build-to-suits and expansions, redevelopment and renovations, and energy solutions. That makes the selection of a buyer-landlord an important component of the sale-leaseback decision. Just as companies consider the terms, capacity and flexibility of a lending relationship when evaluating traditional debt, they should assess whether a prospective real estate partner can support their longer-term needs. The economics at closing matter, but so does the ability of the partner to accommodate the business as it grows and changes. Looking beyond the cost of capital The decision between a sale-leaseback and traditional debt financing is ultimately bigger than the cost of one source of capital versus another. It is a decision about capital allocation. Companies should consider the amount of capital the business needs, its existing capital structure, the strategic importance of owning its real estate and how effectively newly available capital can be deployed. Interested in exploring whether a sale-leaseback could complement your broader capital strategy? Contact W. P. Carey to learn more.
Why Institutional Capital Continues to Embrace Sale-leasebacks
As more corporate and private equity firms have turned to sale-leasebacks, deal volume has continued to grow compared with 10 or 20 years ago. That growth has caught the attention of institutional investors, such as J.P. Morgan Asset Management and Goldman Sachs, who may have previously viewed net lease or sale-leaseback as a niche asset class. “I think as the market has grown, those asset managers have realized that there’s real scale to this market and a real opportunity even for the largest firms,” says Tyler Swann, co-head of North American investments at W. P. Carey. For investors considering sale-leaseback strategies, that growing interest raises questions about how these assets hold up through market cycles and whether increased investor demand is changing pricing. How Critical Real Estate Weathers Market Cycles Swann explains that the sale-leaseback market has an investment track record long enough for investors to see how well assets performed during past market cycles. He also notes that the assets are usually very important to the companies operating them. As a result, even during downturns, companies need the real estate and tend to stick with it. “If you buy highly critical real estate under well-structured leases, that asset tends to remain essential to a tenant’s business,” says Swann. He notes that you can’t necessarily say the same for debt or equity investments, which are more heavily impacted by economic cycles. Swann adds that W. P. Carey is a long-term investor and is less impacted by short-term market downturns, given the company’s leases generally run 15 years or longer. Rising Rates Haven’t Yet Cooled Sale-leaseback Demand Large institutional investors entering the sale-leaseback market suggests that interest continues to grow, but Swann suggests its impact may be minimal on pricing or deal terms. “It seems at this point that every large asset manager has realized that they need a net lease platform in order to offer a full suite of investments to their clients,” says Swann. When considering the months ahead, Swann acknowledges that continued long-term rate increases may affect future deal flow, but notes that demand from tenants and capital sources has remained strong. “The rise in rates that we’ve seen over the last six months hasn’t really had a major impact so far,” says Swann. He points to one area where capital may be getting ahead of itself, which is the trend of very aggressive pricing for assets leased to investment-grade credits. However, he also notes that because W. P. Carey’s core focus is primarily on sub-investment-grade credits, that trend hasn’t had much of an impact on its business to date. Overall, Swann views market pricing as fair and reasonable. And because recent rate increases haven’t had a major effect, he remains optimistic about deal flow over the next 12 months.
Sale-leasebacks Earn a Bigger Role in Capital Strategies
Corporate operators and private equity sponsors are increasingly using sale-leasebacks in their capital strategies, whether to fund acquisitions, manage costs, or improve their balance sheet position. When companies own significant real estate, this structure provides access to the full property value without disrupting operations, says Zachary Pasanen, managing director and co-head of North American investments at W. P. Carey. "Companies often have significant capital tied up in real estate, so a sale-leaseback allows them to monetize the real estate fully, lock in a very long-term contract, and fix their rent for a sustained period of time," Pasanen says, adding that proceeds are commonly used to shore up balance sheets, fund growth initiatives, pay down expensive debt, or address near-term obligations coming due. As more companies weigh their options for unlocking the value of their real estate, the structure's appeal comes down to how well it fits broader capital goals. Private Equity Sponsors Find Value in the Multiple Gap Private equity firms have become steady users of sale-leasebacks to finance corporate acquisitions, Pasanen notes. This structure provides an opportunity to capture value from the gap between the real estate multiple and the acquisition multiple. "You can often find strong accretion by utilizing the sale-leaseback," Pasanen says. He adds that prudent CFOs and sponsors are factoring it into M&A strategies as an additional way to capitalize acquisitions. Corporate operators are also using this structure for other balance sheet purposes. For example, companies looking to pay down near-term or expensive debt may apply sale-leaseback proceeds while maintaining operational control of their facility. "The way we structure a lease gives them effectively the same controls they had when they owned the facility," Pasanen says. He explains that tenants can make alterations within reason, and they remain responsible for taxes, maintenance and insurance, much as they were before the deal closed. Pasanen also notes that W. P. Carey is a long-term capital partner to its tenants and can support their real estate needs as they evolve, with the ability to finance expansions, renovations or energy retrofits at their leased properties. Capital Flows In as Appetite Stays Strong Companies holding real estate often find the structure attractive because it helps them unlock a property's full market value. Pasanen notes that mortgage financing, by contrast, typically returns around 50 to 70 cents on the dollar. Corporate demand for sale-leasebacks is met by a market with no shortage of capital supporting it. Pasanen expects the sale-leaseback market to remain active, noting that a growing pool of investors are entering the space. For specialized facilities where tenants have invested heavily and relocation is expensive, Pasanen says investor demand remains particularly strong. This suggests the structure will remain a viable option, particularly for companies whose real estate is critical to their operations.